Dukaan: A Missed Opportunity in Surrogacy Storytelling

Film – Dukaan

Directors: Siddharth and Garima

Cast: Monika Panwar, Monali Thakur, Sikandar Kher and others

Rating: 2 stars

"Dukaan" attempts to navigate the intricate terrain of surrogacy and its consequences, but unfortunately, it stumbles along the way. Directed by Siddharth and Garima, the film boasts a promising premise but fails to deliver a compelling narrative.

The story follows Jasmine Patel, portrayed by Monika Panwar, a courageous young woman who finds herself entangled in the complexities of surrogacy. After a tragic event leaves her responsible for caring for Sumer's children, Jasmine makes the difficult decision to become a surrogate mother to support herself financially. However, as she becomes emotionally attached to the child she carries, she is forced to confront a moral dilemma that threatens to unravel her life.

While the film tackles a thought-provoking subject matter, its execution leaves much to be desired. The directors struggle to effectively convey Jasmine's emotional journey and the ethical implications of surrogacy. Instead, the narrative relies heavily on melodrama and clichés, failing to delve deeper into the complexities of the issue at hand.

The performances are a mixed bag, with Monika Panwar delivering a commendable portrayal of Jasmine's inner turmoil. However, Sikandar Kher and Monali Thakur fail to leave a lasting impression in their respective roles. Additionally, the film's attempt to emulate the style of other successful films feels forced and unoriginal, detracting from its overall impact.

In conclusion, "Dukaan" falls short of its potential as a thought-provoking exploration of surrogacy. While it has moments of sincerity, the film is ultimately let down by weak storytelling, uninspired performances, and a lack of depth. For those seeking a nuanced examination of the subject, "Dukaan" may not be the most satisfying choice.